The Role of Expert Witnesses in Medical Device Injury Cases

Jump To Section

Home » Blog » The Role of Expert Witnesses in Medical Device Injury Cases
Hollis Law Firm
LEGALLY REVIEWED BY:
Managing Attorney
Last updated on June 11, 2025
NADC logo
Super Lawyers

Medical device injury cases require expert witnesses to establish the credibility and validity of claims. These professionals clarify technical aspects of the case, helping the court understand complex medical and engineering principles. Their testimony influences legal arguments and decisions, making them essential to litigation.

Hollis Law Firm represents people injured by negligence, including medical device injury cases. We have experience working with expert witnesses to get compensation for our clients. In our experience, an expert witness can be the difference between winning and losing a case. 

What Is an Expert Witness?

An expert witness has specialized knowledge, skills, or experience in a relevant field. In medical device injury cases, these professionals explain medical standards, device functionality, and associated risks. Their testimony breaks down technical details so that the jury and judge can comprehend the case. Their findings often determine the case’s direction by providing opinions that shape legal arguments.

An expert’s credibility depends on qualifications such as advanced degrees, certifications, and extensive experience. These credentials give their testimony authority, making their opinions persuasive. When a medical device allegedly causes harm, these experts establish the link between device failure and the plaintiff’s injury. Their insights strengthen or weaken claims, making their presence in litigation crucial.

Types of Expert Witnesses in Medical Device Cases

Medical device injury cases rely on different types of expert witnesses. Medical experts, including physicians and surgeons, assess how a device contributed to a patient’s injuries. Engineering experts focus on design and manufacturing, determining whether the device meets industry safety standards. Each expert provides unique insights that contribute to building a strong case.

Regulatory experts examine compliance with health regulations, while biomechanical experts analyze how device failure affects the body. These perspectives create a well-rounded legal strategy. By consulting various experts, attorneys can present a thorough argument that strengthens a case.

How Expert Testimony Strengthens a Claim

Expert testimony adds credibility to a plaintiff’s allegations in medical device injury cases. These professionals explain medical and technical information in clear terms, allowing jurors to understand the evidence. Their insights help establish a direct connection between the medical device and the plaintiff’s injuries.

Defense teams often present counter arguments, making expert testimony even more important. These professionals clarify technical terms, challenge opposing claims, and provide scientifically supported perspectives. Their ability to articulate findings in a compelling manner strengthens a plaintiff’s argument, reinforcing the case’s foundation.

Medical Experts vs. Engineering Experts

Medical and engineering experts provide different but equally important perspectives in medical device injury cases. Medical experts, including doctors and specialists, focus on diagnosis, treatment, and the health impact of device failure. Their testimony demonstrates the extent of injury and the medical standards relevant to the device.

Engineering experts analyze the technical specifications, design, and manufacturing processes. They determine whether a device meets safety standards or contains inherent flaws. Their testimony clarifies how a defect may have contributed to the injury. By combining these perspectives, attorneys build comprehensive arguments that present a complete picture of the case.

Challenges in Using Expert Witnesses

Expert witnesses strengthen cases, but challenges exist in using them effectively. Biases or conflicts of interest can reduce the credibility of testimony. Attorneys must carefully vet experts to ensure objectivity. Technical complexity also presents obstacles, as experts must communicate intricate details in a way that jurors can understand.

Cost remains another factor, as hiring experts can be expensive. Plaintiffs without sufficient resources may struggle to secure top professionals. Additionally, opposing expert witnesses often present conflicting opinions, requiring attorneys to develop strong strategies to counteract them. Careful selection and preparation ensure expert testimony remains persuasive and beneficial to the case.

Legal Standards for Expert Testimony

Courts enforce strict standards to ensure expert testimony remains reliable and relevant. The Daubert standard requires expert opinions to rely on scientifically valid reasoning and methodologies. This prevents the introduction of unreliable claims that could mislead juries. Experts must show their methodologies are widely accepted and applicable to the case.

A court also examines an expert’s qualifications, including education, experience, and specialized training. These factors determine whether an expert’s testimony will be admitted. Legal professionals must thoroughly vet experts to ensure compliance with these legal standards. Adhering to these rules strengthens a case and ensures testimony holds up in court.

The Impact of Expert Witnesses on Case Results

Expert witnesses influence medical device injury cases by strengthening legal arguments. Well-supported testimony increases the likelihood of a favorable verdict. Jurors depend on expert insights to understand complex issues, making expert testimony one of the most influential elements of a trial.

Defendants often reconsider their positions when facing strong expert testimony. This may lead to settlements before reaching trial. By presenting a compelling case, expert witnesses impact not only court proceedings but also pre-trial negotiations. Selecting the right experts increases the chances of a successful resolution.

Contact Hollis Law Firm for Help With Your Medical Device Injury Case

Legal representation is necessary for medical device injury cases. At Hollis Law Firm, our team understands the complexities involved in these claims and works to ensure clients receive proper legal support. Our attorney collaborates with expert witnesses to construct strong cases that clearly present the facts.

Our firm provides professional guidance throughout the legal process, protecting client rights and advocating for appropriate compensation. Contact Hollis Law Firm today to discuss your medical device injury case and learn how we can assist with your legal needs. Call Hollis Law Firm at 866-262-0890 or fill out our contact form for a consultation.

Author
JASON CHAMBERS, JD
Hollis Law Firm

As the managing attorney at the Hollis Law Firm, Jason Chambers leads complex product liability and personal injury litigations, advocating for clients injured by defective drugs, medical devices, and personal injury accidents. The firm, based in Kansas City, represents victims throughout the Midwest and beyond, offering free consultations to those affected by harmful prescription drugs, defective medical devices, and personal injuries.

Jump To Section
Free Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

800-701-3672
800-701-3672
800-701-3672
800-701-3672
800-701-3672
Hollis Law Firm
8101 College Blvd, Suite 260
Overland Park, KS 66210